Member's Coin Album
Classic light toned frosty finish with original and attractive with warmth, but more subdued than bright white or vibrant rainbow examples | Decent cartwheel effect breaking through the light toning
Premium frosty bright finish with strong luster and clean surfaces with excellent eye appeal and "pop"
Premium toned frosty finish with electric rainbow spectrum that gives huge visual impact and "wow" factor | Strong cartwheel effect breaks vividly through the toning
Classic light toned frosty finish with original and attractive with warmth, providing pleasant contrast and character while retaining the underlying S-mint brightness | Strong cartwheel effect breaking through the light toning
Classic light toned frosty finish with original and attractive with warmth, providing pleasant contrast and character while retaining the underlying S-mint brightness | Strong cartwheel effect breaking through the light toning
Classic frosty/matte with subtle semi-proof like fields w/ booming cartwheel effect luster
Classic frosty/matte with subtle semi-proof like fields w/ booming cartwheel effect luster
OGH | Premium frosty semi-proof like finish with subtle toning on both OBV and REV | Booming cartwheel effect
Strong frosty cartwheel on the white reverse with obverse luster subdued slightly by interesting russet-rainbow hues but still present beneath
Strong frosty cartwheel on the white reverse with obverse luster subdued slightly by interesting russet-rainbow hues but still present beneath
Heavy Golden-Russet to Grayish-Brown toning w/ a Matte/Satin texture | Cartwheel luster is present but subdued
Heavy Golden-Russet to Grayish-Brown toning w/ a Matte/Satin texture | Cartwheel luster is present but subdued
OGH w/verified CAC Green Bean sticker | Premium frosty/matte devices with semi-proof like fields | Vibrant and thick cartwheel effect
OGH | Classic proof like or near deep mirror proof like finish | Frost on raised areas against shiny fields gives it that "black-and-white" pop | Booming cartwheel effect
Premium frosty semi-proof like finish | Booming cartwheel and a developed OBV crescent rainbow
Good frosty cartwheel in untuned centers along with peripheral toning with premium golden-russet and iridescent blue green/violet accents results in desirable "rainbow crescent" hues that softens but enhances rather than dulls the flash
Good frosty cartwheel in untuned centers along with peripheral toning with premium golden-russet and iridescent blue green/violet accents results in desirable "rainbow crescent" hues that softens but enhances rather than dulls the flash
Moderately frosty with pleasing golden russet to iridescent toning. Decent cartwheel effect but the toning mutes the full brilliance
Moderately frosty with pleasing golden russet to iridescent toning. Decent cartwheel effect but the toning mutes the full brilliance
Strong frosty cartwheel, enhanced in the untuned centers | Desirable golden-russet to iridescent blue-violet toning with premium "rainbow crescent" hues
Stunning original toning with vibrant rainbow iridescence. The obverse displays a rich palette of electric blues, magentas, and violets framing Liberty's profile, transitioning to golden-russet highlights in the fields and deeper crimson accents near the rims. The reverse shows more subtle yet complementary toning, with golden centers giving way to teal and purple rim hues over frosty devices. Beneath the colorful patina, the coin retains strong underlying luster with a sharp strike and clean surfaces
Stunning original toning with vibrant rainbow iridescence. The obverse displays a rich palette of electric blues, magentas, and violets framing Liberty's profile, transitioning to golden-russet highlights in the fields and deeper crimson accents near the rims. The reverse shows more subtle yet complementary toning, with golden centers giving way to teal and purple rim hues over frosty devices. Beneath the colorful patina, the coin retains strong underlying luster with a sharp strike and clean surfaces
Attractive toning with moderate golden russet on the obverse with peripheral rainbow hints, and lighter golden on the reverse. Centers remain semi-brilliant with decent frost beneath the toning. Surfaces show typical light abrasions and marks for MS62, but no major distractions
Attractive blast-white core with subtle golden rim toning | Sharp details on hair, stars, and eagle feathers above average for New Orleans mint | Clean fields and devices with minor scattered marks and strong frosty cartwheel luster on both sides, with boom visible through subtle toning
CACG Certification 7448.64/70023207 | Attractive original peripheral toning in warm golden russet hues that frame brilliant silvery centers, with strong cartwheel luster and excellent eye appeal. Obverse shows sharp details on Liberty's hair, cap, and cotton bolls, with minimal marks for the grade and a bold "1878" date. Reverse features a well-struck heraldic eagle, crisp legends, and the clear "S" mint mark, enhanced by matching rim toning.
CACG Certification 7485.62/836630643 | Boasts proof like surfaces with deep mirrored fields and frosty devices, accented by subtle golden toning at the rims for captivating contrast and eye appeal. Obverse features a sharply struck Liberty with flowing hair details, bold cap folds, and clear 1881 date; reverse displays a majestic eagle with crisp feathers, arrows, olive branch, and prominent "O" mintmark.
CACG Certification 7486.64/207920167 | Toned satin/frosty finish with mild reflectivity and subtle iridescent rainbow highlights | Decent cartwheel effect breaking through the toning
CACG Certification 7486.64/207920167 | Toned satin/frosty finish with mild reflectivity and subtle iridescent rainbow highlights | Decent cartwheel effect breaking through the toning
CACG Certification 7490.65/282049337 | Silver Witter Brick | Strike: Well-executed and nicely detailed for the issue—Liberty's hairlines and cap exhibit good separation with crisp definition, stars are sharp, and the eagle's breast feathers show better-than-average separation without the softness sometimes seen on this common P-mint date. A balanced, pleasing impression overall | Surface: Exceptionally clean for MS65; fields are smooth with only the lightest, scattered ticks and micro-abrasions that vanish under normal viewing angles—no heavy bag marks, hairlines, or distractions mar the premium eye appeal | Luster: Radiant satiny-to-frosty cartwheel glow; the strong, rolling luster bounces brilliantly across both sides with that classic mint frost skin, giving the coin a fresh, original look | Toning: Delicate, even golden-silver patina blankets the surfaces with soft peripheral accents of warm honey and faint champagne hues, adding subtle originality and warmth without overpowering the brilliant underlying luster. A restrained, natural tone that enhances rather than dominates.
CACG Certification 7492.65/869330618 | Silver Witter Brick | Strike: Strongly executed with excellent detail throughout, Liberty's hair curls and cap exhibit sharp separation, stars are fully defined and pointed, and the eagle's breast feathers, wing tips, and talons display crisp, above-average separation for the issue. A well-struck example that avoids the occasional softness seen on 1884-Ps | Surface: Superbly clean and premium for the grade; fields are smooth and distraction-free with only the faintest, scattered micro-ticks that require close inspection to detect; no bag marks, hairlines, or spots disrupt the eye appeal | Luster: Blazing satiny-frosty cartwheel brilliance radiates across both sides, the classic mint frost skin of high-end 1884-P Morgans gives it a fresh-from-the-bag glow, with strong, rolling luster that dances under light for outstanding visual pop | Toning: Subtle yet attractive light golden-silver patina blankets the surfaces evenly, with soft warm honey and faint champagne accents hugging the peripheries on both obverse and reverse. This natural, restrained album toning adds warmth and originality without masking the brilliant underlying luster—elegant enhancement rather than heavy color.
CACG Certification 7494.64/983192551 | Strike: Nicely sharp and well-defined for the issue, Liberty's hair curls display good separation and detail, the cap and coronet are crisp, stars are pointed and fully struck, and the eagle's breast feathers, wings, and talons show above-average separation with no significant weakness typical of some 1885-Ps. A balanced, pleasing impression that stands out in the grade | Surface: Exceptionally clean and premium within MS64; open fields are smooth with only light, scattered contact marks and micro-abrasions that are unobtrusive and typical with no heavy bag marks, cheek scratches, hairlines, or spots compromise the eye appeal | Luster: Vibrant and frosty cartwheel brilliance—the classic mint frost skin of top-tier 1885-P examples radiates strongly across both sides, with rolling, satiny glow that bounces brilliantly under light for outstanding visual punch and that fresh-from-the-bag look | Toning: Light, even golden-silver patina covers the surfaces naturally, accented by soft warm honey and faint champagne highlights at the peripheries on obverse and reverse. This restrained, original album toning adds subtle warmth and depth without dominating the brilliant luster—elegant enhancement that boosts overall appeal.
CACG Certification 7600.65/860528056 | Green Witter Brick | Strike: Well-executed and nicely detailed for the issue; Liberty's hairlines and cap exhibit good separation with crisp definition, stars are sharp, and the eagle's breast feathers show better-than-average separation without the softness sometimes seen on this common P-mint date. A balanced, pleasing impression overall | Surface Quality: Exceptionally clean for MS65; fields are smooth with only the lightest, scattered ticks and micro-abrasions that vanish under normal viewing angles with no heavy bag marks, hairlines, or distractions mar the premium eye appeal | Luster: Radiant satiny-to-frosty cartwheel glow, with strong, rolling luster bounces brilliantly across both sides with that classic mint frost skin, giving the coin a fresh, original look | Toning: Delicate, even golden-silver patina blankets the surfaces with soft peripheral accents of warm honey and faint champagne hues, adding subtle originality and warmth without overpowering the brilliant underlying luster. A restrained, natural tone that enhances rather than dominates.
