Rankings as of 5/30/2007 4:09:00 PM
| Rank | Set Name | % Complete | GPA Weighted | Set Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carl Womack Buffalo Collection (Varieties) | 100.00% | 65.111 | 65.111 | |
| 3 | Driftwood Buffalo Nickel Set | 97.22% | 64.565 | 62.801 | |
| 3 | Great Plains Enterprises | 92.96% | 65.465 | 62.070 | |
| 4 | Richard Hennessy collection (varieties) | 97.18% | 65.681 | 61.059 | |
| 5 | Drinen's Buffalo Nickels w/Vars | 97.22% | 62.994 | 60.413 | |
| 6 | Bill Fivaz Collection | 95.77% | 63.866 | 60.081 | |
| 7 | Irv's Herd | 100.00% | 59.426 | 59.426 | |
| 8 | The JDG Trust Collection | 93.06% | 65.964 | 59.295 | |
| 9 | Great Basin Collection | 93.06% | 64.119 | 59.038 | |
| 10 | The Heller Collection | 94.44% | 63.824 | 58.593 | |
| 11 | PocketChange Buffalo Stampede | 97.18% | 59.614 | 55.419 | |
| 12 | Martin's Collection | 93.06% | 61.392 | 55.186 | |
| 13 | Garrow King's Buffalo Nickels | 91.67% | 60.920 | 54.262 | |
| 14 | (deleted set) | 95.83% | 52.517 | 49.361 | |
| 15 | CoolKarma's Full Buffalo set | 77.78% | 62.035 | 48.475 | |
| 16 | (deleted set) | 83.33% | 63.064 | 48.418 | |
| 17 | Larry's Major Variety Buffalos | 98.61% | 38.535 | 37.798 | |
| 18 | (deleted set) | 70.83% | 58.022 | 35.986 | |
| 19 | (deleted set) | 55.56% | 61.536 | 30.768 | |
| 20 | Freds buffalos | 65.28% | 45.063 | 25.609 | |
| 21 | Melvin D. Souza | 39.44% | 64.494 | 20.781 | |
| 23 | KozMc Buffs | 59.15% | 45.881 | 20.052 | |
| 24 | (deleted set) | 55.56% | 50.182 | 22.623 | |
| 24 | (deleted set) | 48.61% | 62.787 | 20.929 | |
| 25 | (deleted set) | 47.22% | 61.791 | 18.571 | |
| 26 | (deleted set) | 38.89% | 64.747 | 16.098 | |
| 28 | (deleted set) | 41.67% | 51.681 | 15.956 | |
| 29 | The Great Plains Collection | 34.72% | 61.127 | 13.194 | |
| 29 | (deleted set) | 36.11% | 62.101 | 15.101 | |
| 31 | M J Hess Collections, Buffalo Nickel Set | 22.22% | 42.542 | 11.158 | |
| 31 | (deleted set) | 25.00% | 65.596 | 09.320 | |
| 32 | romanose05 | 15.28% | 56.466 | 08.948 | |
| 33 | (deleted set) | 25.00% | 65.204 | 08.730 | |
| 34 | (deleted set) | 22.22% | 64.605 | 07.590 | |
| 34 | Sam Martin | 19.44% | 65.781 | 05.751 | |
| 37 | (deleted set) | 23.61% | 36.212 | 06.530 | |
| 38 | Miguel's Bisons | 18.06% | 47.771 | 06.265 | |
| 39 | Raymond Collection | 20.83% | 37.018 | 05.563 | |
| 40 | (deleted set) | 16.67% | 35.500 | 05.432 | |
| 41 | (deleted set) | 12.50% | 40.163 | 05.377 | |
| 42 | ddt oregon Buffalo | 9.72% | 60.161 | 05.096 | |
| 43 | Bear Creek Collection | 15.28% | 64.893 | 04.964 | |
| 44 | (deleted set) | 18.06% | 65.154 | 04.628 | |
| 45 | (deleted set) | 11.11% | 43.395 | 04.505 | |
| 46 | Deegm | 13.89% | 65.250 | 04.279 | |
| 47 | The R. S. Gore Collection | 12.50% | 65.526 | 03.402 | |
| 48 | (deleted set) | 4.17% | 63.750 | 02.787 | |
| 49 | (deleted set) | 5.56% | 66.500 | 01.454 | |
| 50 | J.D.'s Buffalo Nickels | 4.17% | 59.750 | 01.306 | |
| 51 | (deleted set) | 1.39% | 64.000 | 01.049 | |
| 52 | (deleted set) | 4.17% | 64.667 | 00.530 | |
| 53 | ajia | 2.78% | 64.667 | 00.530 | |
| 54 | (deleted set) | 1.39% | 66.000 | 00.180 |