Rankings as of 9/1/2006 9:34:00 AM
| Rank | Set Name | % Complete | GPA Weighted | Set Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gerald Forsythe | 100.00% | 66.469 | 66.469 | |
| 2 | Tom McCarroll | 100.00% | 66.295 | 66.295 | |
| 3 | Pennsylvania Collector | 100.00% | 65.991 | 65.991 | |
| 4 | Larry Whitlow | 100.00% | 65.969 | 65.969 | |
| 5 | Richard Hennessy Collection | 100.00% | 65.964 | 65.964 | |
| 6 | Carl Womack Buffalo Collection | 100.00% | 65.960 | 65.960 | |
| 7 | Beautiful Buffalos | 100.00% | 65.902 | 65.902 | |
| 8 | Donald A. Kutz | 100.00% | 65.768 | 65.768 | |
| 9 | Leon Kontos | 100.00% | 65.652 | 65.652 | |
| 10 | (deleted set) | 100.00% | 65.533 | 65.533 | |
| 11 | Anne Kate Collection | 100.00% | 65.469 | 65.469 | |
| 12 | cape cod buffalos | 100.00% | 65.304 | 65.304 | |
| 13 | Jon/Lor | 100.00% | 65.188 | 65.188 | |
| 14 | JD | 100.00% | 65.138 | 65.138 | |
| 15 | Irv's Herd | 100.00% | 64.942 | 64.942 | |
| 16 | ADM | 98.44% | 65.897 | 64.858 | |
| 17 | (deleted set) | 100.00% | 64.514 | 64.514 | |
| 18 | steelcityman's buffs | 100.00% | 63.505 | 63.505 | |
| 19 | Carnton Collection | 98.44% | 65.360 | 63.505 | |
| 20 | PocketChange Buffalo Herd | 100.00% | 63.232 | 63.232 | |
| 21 | P. Kubler Collection | 100.00% | 62.237 | 62.237 | |
| 22 | Bill Fivaz Collection | 96.88% | 64.609 | 62.013 | |
| 23 | coinlaw | 93.75% | 63.961 | 57.964 | |
| 24 | Garrow King's Basic Buffalo Set | 89.06% | 61.746 | 53.760 | |
| 25 | (deleted set) | 89.06% | 64.757 | 52.909 | |
| 26 | M.E. Stewart Collections | 98.44% | 53.781 | 52.593 | |
| 27 | Bob's Buffalo Nickel Collection - Basic | 87.50% | 63.958 | 52.256 | |
| 28 | CoolKarma's Buffalos | 79.69% | 63.008 | 51.678 | |
| 29 | The Wydeven Collection-TRUEVIEW Herd | 98.44% | 51.313 | 50.666 | |
| 30 | Bruce's Buffalos | 79.69% | 63.699 | 46.016 | |
| 31 | MTB | 82.81% | 60.579 | 44.909 | |
| 32 | Martin's Collection | 78.13% | 63.709 | 44.817 | |
| 33 | East Coast Collection | 70.31% | 65.478 | 40.339 | |
| 34 | (deleted set) | 90.63% | 41.852 | 37.495 | |
| 35 | WCP buffalo's AU+ | 45.31% | 58.157 | 33.940 | |
| 36 | (deleted set) | 57.81% | 64.627 | 28.950 | |
| 37 | CBH Buffalo Nickel Collection | 59.38% | 65.602 | 27.524 | |
| 38 | KozMc Buffs | 62.50% | 48.789 | 23.741 | |
| 39 | (deleted set) | 48.44% | 65.067 | 21.552 | |
| 40 | (deleted set) | 48.44% | 61.471 | 20.167 | |
| 41 | Dave's Set | 43.75% | 63.778 | 18.107 | |
| 42 | The Colorado Buffs | 37.50% | 64.161 | 17.609 | |
| 43 | (deleted set) | 40.63% | 65.073 | 16.833 | |
| 44 | Montana Collection | 35.94% | 57.893 | 15.341 | |
| 45 | (deleted set) | 34.38% | 65.192 | 15.013 | |
| 46 | b bergmann buffalo's | 32.81% | 63.509 | 11.420 | |
| 47 | Dr. Paul's Tatanka Collection | 28.13% | 65.306 | 10.095 | |
| 48 | (deleted set) | 28.13% | 65.204 | 10.079 | |
| 49 | (deleted set) | 14.06% | 62.455 | 08.669 | |
| 50 | (deleted set) | 21.88% | 64.641 | 07.953 | |
| 51 | A simple Buffalo collection | 17.19% | 65.000 | 05.741 | |
| 52 | Buffalo Stampede | 17.19% | 65.259 | 05.558 | |
| 53 | The Milentius II Set | 14.06% | 65.130 | 04.726 | |
| 54 | HKnJameses | 15.63% | 65.000 | 04.716 | |
| 55 | RSD | 12.50% | 64.333 | 03.653 | |
| 56 | The R.S.Gore Collection | 10.94% | 65.462 | 02.685 | |
| 57 | Bear Creek Collection | 9.38% | 65.000 | 02.666 | |
| 58 | CSF | 10.94% | 65.250 | 02.470 | |
| 59 | (deleted set) | 7.81% | 52.083 | 01.972 | |
| 60 | (deleted set) | 9.38% | 65.111 | 01.849 | |
| 61 | (deleted set) | 6.25% | 64.857 | 01.432 | |
| 62 | ajia | 3.13% | 64.667 | 00.612 | |
| 63 | (deleted set) | 1.56% | 66.000 | 00.208 |