PD Shad Modern Commemorative Gold Proofs Revision History

Revision History

This table shows the history of a set from the first time the set was registered to each revision thereafter. The tie breaker revision is defined as the set's earliest revision that the highest rating was achieved. Tie breaker revisions are compared by Rating first and Date second.

Revision #	Revision Time	ATF Rank	Rating	GPA with Top Bonuses	% Complete	Registered Items	Optional Items	Composite Required Items	Notes
	Today	65	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53
	4/11/2025 1:34:05 PM	65	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: WQ Gold Commemorative Proof
	4/11/2025 1:34:03 PM	65	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: WQ Gold Commemorative Proof
	2/17/2025 6:18:42 PM	64	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: WQ Gold Commemorative Proof
	2/17/2025 6:18:25 PM	65	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Manos73
24	2/17/2025 6:18:24 PM	66	20.505	69.033	22.64%	12		53	Set published.
	2/11/2025 3:35:24 PM	64	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	2/11/2025 3:35:23 PM	64	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	1/29/2025 1:36:16 PM	63	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	1/29/2025 1:36:15 PM	63	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	12/17/2024 12:39:53 PM	64	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	12/17/2024 12:39:53 PM	64	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	12/17/2024 11:56:48 AM	63	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	7/10/2024 2:20:07 PM	64	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: GSC
	6/19/2024 11:46:47 PM	63	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: guccieng
	6/6/2024 11:18:16 AM	62	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Big D Brass
	6/6/2024 11:18:15 AM	62	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Big D Brass
	3/26/2024 12:01:00 PM	61	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	3/26/2024 10:42:26 AM	60	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	1/9/2024 11:54:31 PM	61	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	Composite updated.
	1/9/2024 11:53:39 PM	61	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	Other set un-published.
	4/28/2023 3:10:09 PM	62	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Mad Max
	4/28/2023 3:10:07 PM	62	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Mad Max
23	12/22/2022 9:19:41 AM	61	21.351	69.033	24.49%	12		49	Set published.
	12/5/2022 5:40:12 AM	60	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: eads8032
	12/5/2022 5:40:06 AM	60	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: eads8032
	12/4/2022 7:45:07 AM	59	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Terry & Nicole
	12/4/2022 7:45:07 AM	59	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Terry & Nicole
	6/9/2022 2:59:09 PM	58	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	Other set un-published.
	6/9/2022 2:59:08 PM	58	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	Other set un-published.
22	4/13/2022 4:50:02 PM	59	21.800	69.033	25.53%	12		47	Set published.
	7/22/2021 2:57:04 AM	59	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Composite updated.
	7/22/2021 2:56:33 AM	59	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set un-published.
	5/2/2021 2:26:04 PM	60	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	5/2/2021 2:26:04 PM	60	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	5/2/2021 2:25:48 PM	59T	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	5/2/2021 2:25:48 PM	59T	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	2/13/2021 4:13:49 PM	59	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	2/13/2021 4:13:46 PM	59	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Other set published.
	1/29/2021 4:59:18 PM	58	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Manos73
21	1/29/2021 4:59:18 PM	59	22.032	69.033	26.09%	12		46	Set published.
	1/4/2021 8:13:38 AM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set un-published.
	1/4/2021 8:13:37 AM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set un-published.
	11/22/2020 6:19:06 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: mayflower
	11/22/2020 6:19:05 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: mayflower
	11/14/2020 6:27:39 AM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set un-published.
	11/14/2020 6:27:38 AM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set un-published.
	5/12/2020 1:55:49 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	5/12/2020 1:12:12 PM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	5/3/2020 1:20:17 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: matkins079
	5/3/2020 1:20:17 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: matkins079
	1/11/2020 1:59:04 PM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set un-published.
	1/11/2020 1:45:30 PM	59	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Other set published.
20	1/3/2020 2:31:45 PM	58	23.011	69.033	28.57%	12		42	Set published.
19	7/10/2019 5:31:58 AM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Set published.
18	7/2/2019 6:34:05 PM	58	23.270	69.033	29.27%	12		40	Set published.
	6/16/2019 9:42:38 AM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Other set un-published.
	6/16/2019 9:39:08 AM	59	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Other set published.
	5/4/2019 1:42:58 AM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Composite updated.
	5/4/2019 1:41:41 AM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Other set un-published.
	4/25/2019 2:30:19 PM	59	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Horner Commems $5,$10 Gold PR
	3/18/2019 4:04:35 PM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	3/18/2019 1:37:10 PM	57	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	1/21/2019 9:20:03 AM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Other set un-published.
	1/21/2019 9:19:51 AM	59	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Other set published.
17	1/2/2019 1:42:23 PM	58	23.534	69.033	30.00%	12		40	Set published.
	11/26/2018 8:24:24 AM	58	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	11/26/2018 8:24:23 AM	58	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: genoj
	10/28/2018 4:59:44 AM	57	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Other set un-published.
	10/28/2018 4:58:45 AM	58	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Other set published.
	9/3/2018 4:30:00 AM	57	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Other set un-published.
	9/3/2018 4:17:42 AM	58	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Other set published.
	7/6/2018 6:19:14 PM	57	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Marini
	6/9/2018 10:44:00 PM	56	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: jackalfried
	3/6/2018 3:59:03 PM	55	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Amanda.klatt
	2/15/2018 11:49:01 AM	54	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Other set un-published.
16	1/4/2018 3:20:00 PM	55	23.805	69.033	30.77%	12		39	Set published.
	8/30/2017 11:48:38 AM	55	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Tom Carr
	8/5/2017 7:05:37 PM	54	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: The Petschek Set
	8/5/2017 5:31:28 PM	53	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	Composite updated.
	8/5/2017 5:31:22 PM	53	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: The Petschek Set
	6/14/2017 8:18:07 AM	54	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	6/14/2017 8:18:00 AM	53	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET UN-PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	5/13/2017 7:50:09 PM	54	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	Other set un-published.
	3/23/2017 1:00:00 PM	55	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: tlybarger
15	1/9/2017 5:40:08 PM	54	24.081	69.033	31.58%	12		38	Set published.
	8/15/2016 12:06:34 PM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Other set published.
	7/30/2016 9:08:57 AM	53	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Composite updated.
	7/30/2016 9:08:40 AM	53	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Other set un-published.
	6/29/2016 10:07:45 AM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Composite updated.
	6/29/2016 10:07:45 AM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Composite updated.
	6/29/2016 10:07:45 AM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Composite updated.
	6/29/2016 10:05:58 AM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Other set un-published.
	6/20/2016 3:35:14 PM	55	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Crossbard Gold
	2/13/2016 8:47:39 AM	54	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Other set published.
	2/1/2016 3:51:34 PM	53	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: sellhart53
	2/1/2016 3:51:33 PM	53	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: sellhart53
14	1/4/2016 10:20:36 AM	52	24.655	69.033	33.33%	12		36	Set published.
	12/31/2015 8:02:14 PM	52	24.952	69.033	34.29%	12		35	Composite updated.
	12/31/2015 7:47:16 PM	53	24.952	69.033	34.29%	12		35	Other set published.
	5/15/2015 3:05:03 AM	52	24.952	69.033	34.29%	12		35	Composite updated.
13	5/15/2015 3:05:01 AM	52	24.952	69.033	34.29%	12		35	Set published. 1 item added.
	8/30/2011 3:46:19 PM	48	24.952	69.033	34.29%	12		35	Composite updated.
	5/2/2015 1:25:52 PM	53	24.096	68.966	31.43%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Tony's Gold Commemoratives
	5/2/2015 1:25:52 PM	53	24.096	68.966	31.43%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Tony's Gold Commemoratives
	2/12/2015 6:21:16 AM	52	24.096	68.966	31.43%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Manos73
12	2/12/2015 6:21:11 AM	51	24.096	68.966	31.43%	11		35	Set published.
	2/12/2015 2:50:09 AM	52	23.810	68.966	30.56%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	2/12/2015 2:49:23 AM	51	23.810	68.966	30.56%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: driftwood
	2/12/2015 2:48:43 AM	50	23.810	68.966	30.56%	11		35	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Subway Tokens Modern Commemoratives Gold Proof
11	1/2/2015 1:16:25 PM	52	23.810	68.966	30.56%	11		35	Set published.
	11/6/2014 8:19:54 AM	52	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: KingOldie's Modern Gold Commemoratives, Proof
	7/14/2014 2:58:36 PM	51	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: LA modern gold commem pf
	3/16/2014 8:45:14 AM	50	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	Other set un-published.
	3/16/2014 8:42:57 AM	50	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	Other set un-published.
	2/21/2014 1:43:38 PM	51	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Goldminer's Collection
	1/5/2014 1:28:25 PM	50	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	Other set published.
	1/5/2014 1:28:19 PM	50	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	Other set published.
10	1/1/2014 1:05:31 PM	51	24.390	68.966	32.35%	11		34	Set published.
	11/1/2013 7:03:05 AM	51	24.691	68.966	33.33%	11		33	Other set published.
	9/19/2013 10:18:26 AM	50	24.691	68.966	33.33%	11		33	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Subway Tokens Modern Commemoratives Gold Proof
	4/30/2013 9:22:49 AM	49	24.691	68.966	33.33%	11		33	Composite updated.
	4/30/2013 9:22:02 AM	49	24.691	68.966	33.33%	11		33	Other set un-published.
9	12/31/2012 8:35:43 PM	50	24.691	68.966	33.33%	11		33	Set published.
	10/11/2012 11:51:11 AM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set published.
	10/11/2012 11:50:18 AM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set published.
	9/5/2012 9:42:25 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: The Blandon Gold Proof Collection
	9/5/2012 9:41:02 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: The Blandon Gold Proof Collection
	8/23/2012 12:35:03 PM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set published.
	8/23/2012 12:33:39 PM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set published.
	5/12/2012 12:03:33 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Composite updated.
	5/12/2012 12:03:12 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set un-published.
	5/11/2012 5:48:45 AM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Plaza Mayor
	1/20/2012 7:21:08 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Composite updated.
	1/20/2012 7:20:56 AM	49	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Other set un-published.
8	1/13/2012 5:30:25 PM	50	25.000	68.966	34.38%	11		32	Set published. 1 item added. Tie breaker revision.
	10/8/2011 9:12:02 AM	50	24.756	68.964	33.33%	10	1	30	Other set published.
	9/21/2011 9:11:38 AM	49	24.756	68.964	33.33%	10	1	30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Bought for Spot Proofs
	8/30/2011 6:58:58 PM	48	24.756	68.964	33.33%	10	1	30	Other set un-published.
7	6/28/2011 12:54:12 AM	48	24.756	68.964	33.33%	10	1	30	Set published. 1 item added.
	6/28/2011 12:48:14 AM	48	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Composite updated.
	6/2/2011 7:50:27 AM	48	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: jimblasius
	4/27/2011 8:59:57 PM	47	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: ErasmusHall
	5/19/2010 2:30:24 PM	46	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Manos73
	3/11/2010 12:49:19 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set un-published.
	10/7/2009 11:46:31 AM	46	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set un-published.
	8/11/2009 9:10:11 PM	47	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set un-published.
	6/9/2009 6:58:05 AM	48	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Hong Sheng Collection
	5/20/2009 5:13:08 PM	47	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: gromet
	3/22/2009 10:50:29 AM	46	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: pscovey
	3/9/2009 3:13:06 AM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set un-published.
	2/4/2009 11:22:11 AM	46	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: William Meredith Collection
	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set published.
	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Other set published.
	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Composite updated.
	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Composite updated.
	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Composite updated.
6	1/16/2009 7:56:17 PM	45	23.872	68.963	30.00%	9		30	Set published.
	1/15/2009 1:04:02 PM	45	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	Other set published.
	11/19/2008 9:50:00 PM	44	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Feely Proof
	9/27/2008 11:22:00 AM	43	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	Other set published.
	7/25/2008 6:13:00 AM	42	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	Other set un-published.
	7/12/2008 1:00:00 PM	43	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: MGM Collection
	5/26/2008 4:13:00 AM	42	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	Other set published.
	3/20/2008 9:05:00 PM	41	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: CMS Collection
	3/6/2008 8:14:00 AM	40	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: The Good Collection
	2/19/2008 2:48:00 PM	39	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Mac & Sally's Modern Gold Commems.
	2/9/2008 1:32:00 PM	38	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Mac & Sally's Modern Gold Commems.
	1/26/2008 10:50:00 AM	37	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: fwheat
5	1/24/2008 5:31:00 PM	36	24.182	68.963	31.03%	9		29	Composite updated.
	1/13/2008 7:17:11 AM	36	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set un-published.
	1/7/2008 10:01:46 AM	35	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	1/5/2008 2:03:00 PM	37	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set un-published.
	1/5/2008 2:03:00 PM	36	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	1/3/2008 8:04:00 PM	38	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	12/19/2007 6:34:34 PM	35	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	12/10/2007 6:49:00 PM	37	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: ~ The Madison Collection: Modern Commem Proof Gold Set ~
	11/11/2007 5:40:53 AM	34	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	11/8/2007 9:45:00 AM	36	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: jhawryluk
	10/9/2007 12:34:52 PM	35	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set un-published.
	10/9/2007 12:34:39 PM	34	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	9/5/2007 4:51:00 PM	36	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	3/19/2007 3:25:42 AM	33	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	2/6/2007 8:11:00 AM	35	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
	1/29/2007 6:29:00 PM	34	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: Gene B. collection
	1/25/2007 8:29:00 PM	33	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: driftwood
	1/22/2007 6:56:00 PM	32	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	OTHER SET PUBLISHED: T&R Sacks Gold Commemoratives
	11/17/2006 11:25:14 AM	28	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Other set published.
4	10/5/2006 12:53:00 AM	31	24.827	68.963	33.33%	9		27	Set published. 2 items added.
3	4/2/2006 8:23:00 AM	32	19.320	69.000	25.93%	7		27	Set published. 2 items added.
2	3/14/2006 8:11:00 AM	34	12.880	69.000	18.52%	5		27	Set published. 1 item added.
1	2/28/2006 12:34:00 AM	36T	10.120	69.000	14.81%	4		27	Set published. 4 items added.

PD Shad Modern Commemorative Gold Proofs Revision History

Revision History This table shows the history of a set from the first time the set was registered to each revision thereafter. The tie breaker revision is defined as the set's earliest revision that the highest rating was achieved. Tie breaker revisions are compared by Rating first and Date second.